smirkstudios's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Nim Vind Music Video]

neat

this was really neat. everything was real clean looking, but not much in the ways of animation. maybe just work on your stuff looking a little more fluid and realistic when it is moving, ok? think physics. sorry for the 6

RatiganZombie responds:

Thank you for your feedback I really appreciate it.

[Ska'd for Life]

short

did you know there is an i in animator? it looks like ANIMATIOR, just wondering if that's how it's supposed to be in the opening credits.

JTricks responds:

Thanks for pointing it out, it's a typo.

[Grand Theft Santa]

we know

we all know how the voting system works. telling people how to vote is against the rules. it is what it is. i'm glad you drew this up yourself, and i'm glad it took you 2 days, but if you look at my hacky sack and ola contest entries, they both are 2 day animations, and you can really see the difference. shape tweens are cheating, and your characters' mouths move in a very non smoothe fashion. i'm afraid you're gonna need plenty of practice before submitting anything worthwhile. good luck bud, and sorry for the low score.

coolcanadiandude responds:

How is shape tweening againts the rules tho?!?!?

[DrMario not in Brawl?]

well

your frame by frame could use some work, but this is pretty cool, and a cool idea. i really like the backgrounds. the appartments where Dr. Mario lives are very cool looking.

Shishizurui responds:

that was a unique perspective, originally it was supposed to be the hospital where he worked.

[30 Seconds (clay)]

this is cool

this is cool, but dont put christmas music to non christmas stuff. also, this is less than 30 seconds. the quality of claymation was awesome, but you should spend more time on it (i know it takes time to do that stuff, but this could go on) upload a more elaborate version where more happens, ok? sorry for the 6

ATOMICCLOUD responds:

I could, but to be honest, i just finished this earlier on Christmas Eve NIGHT. I might maybe, but to be honest right now i just feel like leaving it as it is.

[i love santa]

wow

that's a morbid way to get your point accross i suppose. i would like to assume that you are in good shape :P

newto responds:

Yea, my intention of drawing this clip is to provide a answer to a question I had since I am a child : why santa never visit me at all. So probably this is the reason? Hmm. hehe, I am in good shape ( i think.. : )
Just want try something diff. thanks for the score!

[SBC's Metal Concert]

no good

this is not very good. nothing about this was in any way good. the sound was terrible, the animation was VERY lacking... maybe next time draw your own characters and do lots more frame by frame work. capn crunch shoulda been head banging, and he wasnt. the guitar that was used should have been in tune. sorry bro

[Sketched-Merry Sketchmas]

dang

everytime! sketched is definately one of my fav series on NG. man, i was hopin for the daily 5th, but my cartoon didnt have the material worthy :D and if i'm up against this, it's no wonder. congrats on daily second place!!! you earned it :D

sirjeffofshort responds:

Thanks for the review. I actually watched your short this morning and I really enjoyed it. I'll leave my actual review over on your short, but I did enjoy it.

It is always tough submitting your material on NG because great stuff is constantly being submitted and it's real easy for quality material to get snubbed. Not to mention the stress that comes with the combination of a voting system and the fact that the internet isn't exactly known for harboring the nicest people in the world, so it always makes me happy to see artists working together and honestly appraising each others work.

Again, thanks for the review.

[WC christmas flash '08]

cool man

this is a little too slide-showy for me, but pretty cool anyways. i like the snow falling on that girl. is that sinatra i hear?

herby62 responds:

thank you. and yes, it is indeed sinatra.

[Little Aviator]

my gosh

very nice work. your scene angles and story work make this a very heart warming clip. definately pro work here.

KartuneHustla responds:

Thanks man. Yeah, I really wanted to try out new camera angles. Usually alot of cartoons keep a flat perspective. It was fun too because most of the angles were a big challenge, especially the part where he runs into his father. Took me one total day to just do the planning and animatics for that scene. Thanks for the review man. I'll tell you that storyboarding definitely helped me plan out everything